Qatato

Barbie/Fulla, where do we stand?

Blog

11 Comments


Share this post

Jamil and jamila

So that what happens when Barbie and Ken moved to Saudi Arabia for Ken’s work?
Jamil and Jamila are the newest abomination in the series of knocking off the famous Matel’s dolls: Barbie and her hubby Ken, and if you have not seen Fulla yet, take a look now.

Fulla

Now, let’s all calm down and take a slow deep breath and try to figure out what the hell went wrong with these “dolls”.
Basically, these are not dolls to start with… this is a pure religious-political propaganda being forced on the Arab kids in all stores, and if you’ve puked few times watching the absurdity of the Arab Cartoon Chanel: Space Toon you would have instantly realized two things: first, how right wing this channel is and it is not a joke, and secondly, how they advertise everything in all ways.
Speaking of Space Toon advertising, “Fulla” cereals, bed sheets, notebooks and other things are available in shops near you now!

So back to the subject of why this is so wrong.
When were we little and our sisters (or we) played with Barbie dolls, have you ever stopped to question what religion or faith she followed or belonged to? have we thought if she was a bad person or not? or has the idea of Barbie being “infidel” even crossed our minds? the typical answer would be NO, provided you lived in a sane healthy environment which explained to you why Ken has no penis when you asked.
Fulla and her new friends (Jamil and Jamila) are the worst example of religious brainwash for the children.
Let’s speak facts!
Q. Who watches Space Toon?
A. Middle class families and below, why? upper class kids have Disney, CN and Nick channels, and it is not only a matter of wealth, there is a free-to-air kids’ channel on the Nilesat Satellite namely MBC3 (part of the MBC group) which is still moderate in content but less conservative in presentation (and no apparent brainwash, luckily), at least the presenter girl in MBC3 is not covered up.
Q. Who buys Fulla? Who buys Barbie?
A. Same answer above. Barbie dolls are considered expensive in the Arab world, at least for below-middle-class families, they simply can not afford an original Barbie doll made my Matel, the kids would not really tell the difference of the high quality material and even the hygienic aspects considered manufacturing the doll, let alone the whole aestheticism of it all, they are blindfoldedly substituted with a cheaper fragile knock off made with no cosideration to any standards and overall contains loads of toxic material in their material; “Fulla” and her faithful friends come to the rescue, not as an original solution to the problem of poverty but as a cunning advertising trick to take advantage of those who are disadvantaged.
Q. Are below-middle-class section large?
A. relatively speaking, yes. According to the CIA Fact book most of Arab countries have a troubling percentage of people living under the poverty line, Iraq alone has 25% of its population falling below that line, Egypt 20% (which I think is more than that, unless they lowered the bar), Jordan 14% (again, I doubt that), except gulf countries which are all marked as NA (none). Again, we are talking about the percentage of people falling below the poverty line which means that even “Fulla” can be a luxurious item for the kid. Excluding Gulf countries, all Arab countries must be considered “poor” which leads us again to the whole religious-socio-economical circle of con and deceit. Poverty is most likely to be associated with illiteracy and taboos of all kinds. Go figure!
Q. What are the prices of both dolls?
A. Barbie and Fulla both come in different shapes, collections and bundles, the prices are mostly to be set according to the value of the package itself. but according to a credible website like Amazon, you can shop for a Barbie doll starting from 20 USD up to 200 USD, and these are just the regular items, no collectibles. Fulla, on the other hand, is not found on Amazon, there must be an Amazonian rule forbidding the existence of religious toys, but Fulla has her own website which is a mediocre pink vomit annoying website, it does not show prices though, but leave that to me, as I see her on all the toy section shelves in all major supermarkets and toy stores in Amman, Fulla’s range is between 10 – 20 USD, bundles include: morning prayer or night prayer besides many others.
Q. Values?
A. Barbie was used in all societies to present the “good girl” value, being considered a “fashion” doll, it also reflected a certain importance for all girls on taking care of themselves, and we are not talking about empty vanity, I won’t go so far to ponder the idea that Paris Hilton is the way she is because she had too many Barbies, actually there is a Barbie that is Paris Hilton now! Barbie also helped little kids into many psychological and ethical aspects including discipline and manners, a girl who could take care of her doll house and throw the most perfect tea party would possibly grow up to be a girl with ambitions and goals, boys most of the time crashed cars ,and look at them boys now (Joke!), but Barbie is a liberal free-spirited gal who loves fashion, jewelries and good things in life, and that is not a bad thing at all, unless you are a Mormon or a Saudi. Speaking of which (Saudis), and read carefully: “The Committee for the Propagation of Virtue and Prevention of Vice stated “Jewish Barbie dolls, with their revealing clothes and shameful postures, accessories and tools are a symbol of decadence to the perverted West.” (Wikipedia). I’d still love to think of myself as an intelligent person who can read and analyze facts, but that statement is just an oxymora! or rather a spiteful hateful non-sense. The Saudi government had outlawed Barbie dolls in 2003, Barbies are an army of invading infidels, or were they? and here comes our hero to the rescue: FULLA, a full-fledged Muslim icon and idol to be kids’ sole option to be loved and taken care of even if you’d rather strip her down her ugly outfits that look like tents anyway. The Fulla fever emerged right after the Barbie outlaw, a well-studied advertising tactic that is, and later on became a Space Toon‘s favorite gal! According to Fulla’s makers NewBoy, Fulla is “A Girl’s Dream Doll”, Full is considered to be the savior of the tradition and culture (and it is the job of the Arab women only anyway), it is all about your family’s honor (Jamil would kill Jamila if she spoke with the Supermarket’s cashier).

So?
Let me conclude: You strip the population from free choice by outlawing a “doll”, you impose a new model that promotes your relatives sales and keep the naive in your grip, you make the prices incredibly cheap so it is accessible to lower classes those who are hungry enough to have nothing but “faith”, and in most cases, distorted perspective of it, You go further more to make a kids’ channel very right-winged that all the cartoons are dubbed in a certain religious way and the main aim of that channel is to promote a certain toy manufacturer… Sir, I think that’s a bingo!

The issue of Barbie Vs. Fulla is huge but not spoken of. In its simplest form, this feud shows how our societies are drifting towards what’s being forced on them without questioning, on how to implement religion in the wrong ways, and most importantly, that an Arab woman is still considered a cheap commodity with a price set by the society, she is the one who is going to cover herself up to save her country’s traditions and culture and she is the one who is going to be always silent and take the back seat.

Fulla is not capable of making love like Barbie, Fulla is an order taker, she has been, and alway will be.

Note on first photo of Jamil and Jamila: notice how Jamil’s Arabic name is still “Jamila” which also refers to Jamil’s secret identity, could Jamil be Jamila with Ken?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=647055045 Mimsi Alm

    100% true am with you in all of that ! i think from my opinion the children at their age don’t think about the religious of the doll ! now they will ! plus i think this will kind of build a religious discrimination which will eventually be a nigative impact to their life and the way they deal with other religious !

  • Hazem Alagha

    Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and you clearly are a very opinionated person and seriously, thumbs up for that, because nobody can take that right away from you. I just want to say that, I read your articles regularly and quite enjoy doing so, however, I may not always agree with you (this doesn’t negate the fact I still enjoy your articles and respect your opinion.

    With this article, I can probably guess that you were born into a muslim family but chose to follow your own beliefs (apologies if this is not true). With this, I feel like your judgement on islamic ‘tools of propaganda’ is a bit clouded….

    I have 3 sisters and no brothers and I can clearly recall the female orientated games I had no choice but to take part in. I can also clearly recall my younger sister asking my mom for a barbie doll. none of my sisters EVER had barbie dolls and never asked for them before. this prompted my mother to buy my sister a Jasmine doll (from alladin). Her reasoning behind this is that Jasmine is technically an arab…..and barbie is technically a white, blonde, blue eyed american. something my sister could not really relate to.

    As we lived in England pretty much our entire childhood, my parents found ways to adapt to the western culture but without sacrificing our Arab roots. A decision I will be eternally grateful for! I do not see anything wrong with my parents doing this as now I have the best of both worlds!

    I remember almost 10 years ago, before the emergence of the fulla dolls, my father’s business partner was in the business of making the first muhajaba doll. her name was Noor. my younger sister was given a prototype and was ecstatic to receive a doll that looked like her aunts and cousins back home… (bare in mind she was born and raised in England)

    when you say that the fulla doll is a brand new way to brainwash children into being muslim……I’m still not sure why this is so evil when her american counterpart does the exact same thing. young girls wanting to be stick thin big breasted pouty mouth bimbos is just as bad… and i can recall many an awkward conversation with my female friends at secondary school who describe in explicit detail how they directed their own pornos starring barbie and ken…..

    teaching a young girl to be pious, modest, faithful etc through this doll is by no means wrong and to be honest, anything barbie can do fulla can do just as well…

    I feel that, you are too quick to criticise Islam and anything to do with Islam when the opportunity arises. 90% of the women in my family are muhajabaat and they are by no means oppressed order takers……….

    im sure i have missed out a few things but i think you get the point….

    • http://ahmadqatato.com Qatato

      Made a new comment instead of a reply, my bad, read above please. :)

  • http://ahmadqatato.com Qatato

    Hazem, your comment is much respected, and I love what you’ve said.
    I apologize if I sounded “against Islam” as a religion, my true purpose was to show the ignorance of the undertakers of the religion (Aka Saudis), because it is their fault how they misinterpreted every little aspect of Islam, I respect all religions and faiths that promotes love and peace for humanity.
    Kids who develop self-image issues are not usually because of a doll but it is a projection, psychologically speaking, no one can develop a complex out of a doll, it is the lack of warmth/love/communication in the house that leaves the kid to their broken selves.
    The point is, we should not bottle religion in dolls, on the other hand, it is absolutely ridiculous that Saudi outlawed Barbie (they outlawed Mickey Mouse last year by the way), and as I mentioned it is not only religious, it is also socio-economical: religion can be misinterpreted in the wrong hand, especially the empty hungry hands.
    By the way, all my nieces love Fulla :) she looks like their moms (my sisters) and my mom (their grandma) who are all liberal intelligent women who wear Hijab by chocie, so I liked what you said “a doll that looked like her aunts and cousins back home”.

    You mentioned an important point: Barbie as a white blond icon, I’ve seen that complex while visiting India, I would not generalize of course, but looking at advertisements everywhere: it only shows “white” people, and there is an Indian Barbie, which is not as popular as other white ones, go figure!

    Again, I apologize if I sounded offensive, I understand where you are coming from and where you are standing and I loved reading your comment (twice). It’s the advertising ghouls that use religion as a tool to sell their products that ticked me off.

    But there are others who are smarter than Saudis in doing so:
    http://www.jewlicious.com/2006/10/indie-minyan-barbie/

    • Hazem Alagha

      Qatato, no apologies are due. you are completely entitled to your opinion and i respect that. although, i may have to apologies if my wording was a bit strong.

      I do agree that the undertakers of religion have the responsibility to well…act responsible…..

      i still have to disagree about the whole self image issue, as it is so evident in western society and increasingly in eastern society, as supermodels and barbie dolls are used to make women (and increasingly men) to feel inadequate in their own skin and thus become obsessed with self image.

      so although you have a point with the fulla doll, it isn’t fair to say that the barbie doll doesn’t seek to do the same thing…

  • Walid

    I think what Mr Q was getting at is the indoctrination going on, the hijab is a choice, but where is the choice when you have gotten a 3 year old to wear it, then it is not a choice but again “brainwashing”. Ahmad touched upon that, I see it in the ads the dichotomy of shooting an ad, same ad done twice one with a hijab and the other without…
    When you use toys to do that then it really does stink of evil propaganda.
    Children should be children and they should be left to be that, when I see a young child dressed in a hijab I look at the parents and think, damn, perverts, to turn a kid at that age into a sexual object because after that is what they are doing by making her wear a hijab, they have instantly put her into a category of a lust worthy object.
    The hijab is a choice, and it gives its wearer a dignity and modesty, that is how I see it, and to use toys for nefarious purposes such as indoctrination makes me livid.

  • SBETTO

    first,i like your articles and videos ,its so real…may i have some Objections,but still OK.
    thanks for the article,but with all respects i think it is not true-in some paragraphs-why you consider that the-mohajjabeh-barbie is religious-political aim…its just indicator for oriental women,its OK for me,if i don’t like it i can buy the original barbie.
    man,you said that is that the barbie-mohajjabeh one-for Middle class families and below,its a fact..they believe that they should be good to have god Mercy and forgiveness and reflect that on thier children,so we should respect their Orientations.
    and for me i hate spacetoon.

    • http://ahmadqatato.com Qatato

      Space Toon and I forgot to mention “Toyoor Al Janna” but that would be for another post, I’m not against Hijab or Islam, I’m just saying how wrong it is to use that as an advertising scheme, that’s all.

  • http://profiles.google.com/sasha.jovanovic Sasha Jovanovic

    This is a perfect example of how a western company is not sensitive to a foreign culture, Mattel is only continuing to lose ground to Fulla in an international girl fight.

    Sasha Jovanovic
    Diverse Prophet
    http://bit.ly/ediFA9

  • ai

    I am a moslem girl (not in Saudi) and I play Barbie instead of Fulla. I feel no difference between Barbie and Fulla; I even dress my Barbie in hijab which my mom made for her. She’s just look as beatiful as she should be ;)
    I also agree with the writer, it’s unwise to use any nationality, religion and/or belief as advertising.

  • Goose

    I wouldn’t normally pay attention to any post considering political or religious views  but I have to agree on every word you’ve mentioned here.
    But the thing that got me more into this post is the fact that you’ve mentioned spacetoon, I used to really love this channel as a child (although even as a child I knew the conflict between Israel, the country I was born and still living in, and most of the middle eastern countries; that, however, didn’t really matter to me, all I cared about was the cartoon. One day, there was some sort of advertisement (I’m not sure how to call it) displaying little guys crawling from the countries surrounding Israel into it and turning the flag into the palastanian flag instead.
    Now I didn’t know what that meant by the time or why the hell they were viewing such material on a kids cartoon channel; I didn’t really understand what kind of message they were trying to pass was it “Hey kids, let’s chase the Jews away!” or “let’s try to find a better way.”? Now this random rant is just an example of yet another political issue they were forcing on KIDS, I’m not saying displaying the issue for debate, I’m saying forcing because they’re KIDS, the easiest creatures to brainwash on the planet. 
    Now back to the Fulla issue, I actually liked it at first, but then it hit me, I’m not a Muslim, I’m an Arab but why would this display an Arabic girl or represent me? I don’t wear a hijab, I don’t have morning/evening prayer, I don’t agree in 3/4 percent of the values she’s trying to teach either ,what the hell? 
    Did they even take into consideration that there are maybe a non-Muslim population in middle eastern countries?
    But that’s not the issue here, it’s getting more personal because my little brother is also watching Spacetoon. 
    On a side note: they totally ruined Ranma 1/2 for me with the stupid dub.